Home · Sell My Business in NJ · Broker or Sell It Yourself
For NJ Business Owners · Decision Guide
Brokers will tell you to hire a broker. Owners who have sold on their own will tell you to save the fee. Both are right in some situations. This page sets out when each makes sense for a New Jersey business, what a broker has to earn to be worth the fee, and what you take on if you sell it yourself.
Part of our guide to selling a business in New Jersey.
Most owners do not need to choose on principle. The situation decides it. Find the row that describes yours.
| Your situation | Usually better | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A buyer is already at the table: a family member, a key employee, a partner, or a competitor who approached you | Sell it yourself, with a transaction attorney and a CPA | The hardest part of a broker’s job, finding and screening buyers, is already done. What you need is a fair price and correct paperwork. |
| No buyer yet, and you want the best price the market will pay | A broker | Price is set by competition. One buyer negotiating alone sets the price; several qualified buyers reviewing at once move it. |
| Staff, customers, suppliers or the landlord must not find out early | A broker | A blind listing that does not name the business, and an NDA signed before any buyer learns who you are. |
| You still run the business full time | A broker | A sale takes 6 to 9 months of buyer calls, document requests and lender questions. If you do that yourself, the business usually suffers while it is being sold, and buyers see it in the numbers. |
| The business is worth mostly its equipment and inventory | Sell it yourself, or list it on a marketplace | There is little goodwill to compete for, and a broker’s minimum fee can be a large share of a small price. |
| You have sold a business before and have an attorney who does these deals | Either | Experience narrows the gap. The question becomes whether you have the time and whether you can reach enough buyers. |
The short version: use a broker when you need buyers, confidentiality or your own time back; sell it yourself when the buyer is already found.
The fair way to compare is your net, not the price. You pay a transaction attorney and a CPA either way, so the difference is the broker’s fee. A broker is worth it only if the price is higher by more than the fee. The table uses our own fee schedule (10% on the first $1 million, 8% from $1 million to $5 million, 6% from $5 million to $10 million, $0 upfront):
| If you could sell it yourself for | Our fee at that price | Brokered price needed to net the same | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| $400,000 | $40,000 | $444,400 | 11.1% higher |
| $750,000 | $75,000 | $833,300 | 11.1% higher |
| $1,500,000 | $140,000 | $1,652,200 | 10.1% higher |
| $3,000,000 | $260,000 | $3,282,600 | 9.4% higher |
So the test is simple: with a 10% fee, a broker has to get you about 11% more than you would get on your own to leave you even. Ask any broker you interview how they expect to do that for your business. The honest answers are competition between several buyers, buyers you would not have reached, a price defended in due diligence instead of renegotiated, and terms (cash at closing, the size of a seller note, how long you stay) that are worth money even when the headline price is the same.
Some firms also charge upfront retainers or monthly marketing fees whether or not the business sells. Those change the arithmetic: a retainer is paid even if the sale never happens. Our 2026 NJ broker fee guide lists what to ask about.
You do not need a broker or any licence to sell your own business. You do need to do, or hire out, everything a broker would do:
Owners who sell a business themselves most often lose ground in the same places: one buyer with no competition sets the price; employees hear about it early; months go to a buyer who could never get financing; and the price is cut in due diligence because the earnings in the offer were not supported by the tax returns.
If you decide to use a broker, our guides to choosing a business broker in New Jersey and finding one list the questions to ask.
Use a broker if you do not already have a qualified buyer, need the sale kept confidential, or still run the business full time. Sell it yourself, with a transaction attorney and a CPA, when the buyer is already found, such as a family member, key employee, partner or competitor. With a 10% fee, a broker has to get you about 11% more than you would get on your own to leave you even.
Yes. You do not need a broker or any licence to sell your own business. You do need a transaction attorney for the purchase agreement, a CPA for the tax and price allocation, and the buyer must file New Jersey’s bulk sale notification, Form C-9600, at least 10 business days before closing.
It varies by firm. Nexus Bridge charges 10% on the first $1 million, 8% from $1 million to $5 million and 6% from $5 million to $10 million, with nothing upfront, paid at closing only if the business sells. Some firms also charge retainers or monthly fees; ask before you sign.
There is no reliable public figure that isolates it, so be wary of any single percentage. The break-even is arithmetic: at a 10% fee the brokered price has to be about 11% higher to leave you even. Brokers earn that through competition between several buyers, reaching buyers you would not, and defending the price in due diligence.
A non-disclosure agreement, a letter of intent, an asset purchase agreement and bill of sale, lease assignment if the landlord consents, IRS Form 8594 (filed by buyer and seller), and New Jersey Form C-9600 (filed by the buyer or the buyer’s attorney). Licences and permits that must transfer have their own applications.
You can, but treat the competitor like any other buyer: an NDA before anything is shared, proof of funds, and customer lists and pricing released only late in due diligence. A competitor who approached you is one bid; finding out whether others would pay more is the main reason to involve a broker.
Yes. Nexus Bridge values New Jersey businesses free and with no obligation, and many owners use the number to negotiate with a buyer they already have. Call (201) 400-9827.
No obligation. No upfront fee. We reply within 1 business day.

Boutique business brokerage for owners across New Jersey, New York, NYC & Connecticut. $0 upfront. Success-based fee only.